Blue, lots of the posts above contain great information, reliable experience, and reports that hold rules of thumb learned (at high cost probably) by the poster.
One thing I'll suggest reading them is a repeat of the post where the locale, your neighborhood plays a roll in what you can offer? For example, it appears there's not much high end architectural detail metal work in Kansas but there are lots of pipe corrals? SO I'd translate that into - first step is to define what is 'needed' or 'wanted' in your neck of the woods and next to determine if you can produce competitively- that item. If so? Can the Chicoms provide that item the HomeTrainStationCo.? cheaper than you can?
Next thing, I think has been said in different ways is: your post seems to request others' designs be given to you? Maybe not what you're asking but it struck me odd that you'd post a request to see others' products? At least that's how I read it? I'll assume you're NOT really asking for wwebber's plans to be emailed to your address?
Now, my prime point, not fully explored here but at least hinted at by others: I've made my main living by design innovation. When I had a fab shop, most work came because of my designs. When I had a welded aluminum boat building shop, almost all the work came to get my boat designs. When I was doing industrial controls systems for the oil and gas business- I know the majority of the work came to me so I'd design and build control automation systems for clients.
Therefore .... while others' experiences are valid and I'd ask you to weigh them in your considerations... my version of finding a niche is the original concept and final design element can attract people to your business. IF you don't have developed design skills, then you might want to explore those who do have those skills- assuming your original post about products that are successful is still operative- so you can build from their designs?
Example: If you show up to the weekend swap meet/craft fair with a dozen steel panels that were cut on your new plaz table that you cut using a cut and paste file that came with the NC table? then you should expect to get "20 bucks each" which will not make wages, materials, table time, painting time..... costs! Why?
Everybody at the craft fair has the same cookie cutter stuff- unless you set yourself apart (using your own innovative designs or hiring/partnering/buying designs) you're confined to the low end of the market.
On the other hand if you're able to draw, draft, and perhaps NC cut your own files- you're able to command a much higher price for similar art/products/fabrications compared to the cut and paste images so commonly offered.
I'm using NC/plaz table work as an example, not suggesting that is what you plan. If your products are not unique it is likely they'll be very marginally profitable. (however) If your skills allow you to join the architectural market, not likely if you're just starting? then again, the reason they pay more is the amount of money spent on high quality design.
I'm trying to both summarize some of the remarks above and encourage you to self-assess honestly while doing real to life, honest market exploration: doing both before you get started can save lots of money and potentially wasted time.
Cheers,
Kevin Morin
As I read this post, the first thing I thought when I read the first bold part: It's actually common in the CNC Plasma world. Everybody seems to think plasma tables are "the easy button to quick money" at craft fairs. At least the majority of the people on various forums/cnc groups. They aren't looking to improve their skills or anything. They buy an entry level machine, and the first thing they ask, "What sells?" But they aren't fabricators, welders, or anything, they are accountants, they are restaurant workers, they are grocery store clerks, etc. Everything but welders, fabricators, skilled trades. They may make a bunch of money on the side, then they are back the next year, "What sells?". Within a few years, many sell the machines.
When I went to school for welding, I had already been a mechanic for 10 years and was had been involved with motorsports for a few years. We had a CNC Plasma for our welding program. The instructors used it as a tool to teach/reinforce blueprint reading/drawing. Everybody else in my class was part of two groups: younger guys who just did the minimum to get by, or the older guys who wanted to be big money pipe welders. Neither of those groups showed interest in the CNC, just did plans because it was required. I saw it, and my first reaction was "I could make this... I could make that..." I downloaded a free 2D CAD program, and I ran with it. Right out of school, I landed a CNC plasma job that payed well more than all my other classmates. I've been in production/manufacturing for many years (CNC and welder), and now back to automotive, but more on the offroad fabrication side. Now I play with a few 3D CAD programs for fun. I'm still young enough to still work hard, but I'm getting old enough that it's taking a toll, and I recognize that at some point I need to slow down and plan for that chapter in my life.
Will I go into my own business? Probably not, but I may do it on the side. Prototyping and small run production. The one thing I refuse to do is craft shows.
Finding your niche is definitely up there on the priority list. Setting yourself apart is also up there. As for running a business directly, I cannot give any advice. But I've seen so many entry level businesses close doors after a few years, whether it be automotive/offroad or CNC for craft shows.
As for continuing education, always learn. The local community college has a "Workforce Training" program. They have business classes, some for cheap. They are always changing. When I was a mechanic, there was a class for bidding jobs. I didn't see a need at the time. It's not available now, but I wish I would have taken it. Infact, there is currently a class for prototyping with 3D CAD, perfect for me.
https://northidaho.augusoft.net/index.cfm?fuseaction=1010
Now that I live in Atlanta, the community colleges in the North Metro area don't have programs like this. You have to be in a degree program to access classes like this.